Skip to Content

Poor Mans Lobster Recipe

Table of Contents show

What Is The Difference Between Poor Man’s Lobster And Regular Lobster?

Poor Man’s Lobster is defined as lobster meat that has not been boiled or cooked in any other method than steaming.

The lobsters used must have come from the ocean and have not been frozen.

Regular Lobster, on the other hand, is defined as lobster meat that has been processed in one way or another before being sold at restaurants and supermarkets.

This includes boiling, freezing, drying, smoking, salting, and pickling.

There is no clear distinction between “poor man’s lobster” and “regular lobster,” so it is difficult to determine which seafood you should buy if you want to eat good quality seafood.

The price

One can argue about whether or not there is really a huge difference in prices between a poor man’s lobster and a regular lobster.

You will pay around $10 per pound for a poor man’s lobster while you will only spend $4-5 dollars per pound when buying a regular lobster.

However, this does mean that poor man’s lobster is much less expensive to cook compared to regular lobster.

If you decide to purchase poor man’s lobster then you should consider how many people would like to eat it and what they prefer with their meal.

If you are looking for something cheap but delicious then this may just be the perfect option for your next dinner party!

A better alternative to shrimp cocktail

While both types of lobster provide an excellent source of protein, vitamins, minerals, and healthy fats, poor man’s lobster provides a variety of nutrients that would otherwise be missing in a standard shrimp cocktail.

One example is zinc, which is essential for growth, wound healing, and immune system function.

Poor man’s lobster also contains higher levels of selenium, which contributes to the body’s ability to fight off cancer cells.

In addition, poor man’s lobster contains lower amounts of sodium compared to its regular counterpart.

Better alternatives to crabmeat

Crabmeat is often considered a delicacy because of its high fat content and rich flavor.

While crabmeat is extremely nutritious, it is also very fatty.

Poor man’s lobster offers a healthier substitute for crabmeat.

It contains fewer calories and has a similar texture to crabmeat.

Furthermore, poor man’s lobster contains higher concentrations of vitamin B12, iron, calcium, phosphorus, magnesium, potassium, and dietary fiber.

Therefore, poor man’s lobster makes a great alternative to crabmeat in dishes such as crab cakes and chicken salad sandwiches.

If you have never eaten lobster before, then this article will help you understand what makes it special.

What Is The Nutritional Value Of Poor Man’s Lobster?

Lobster has long been considered as one of the most expensive seafood in restaurants all over the world because they are very hard to catch.

However, it doesn’t mean that the quality isn’t good at all.

In fact, there are many different types of lobsters from different parts of the world.

The main difference between them is their size.

The biggest ones can reach up to 10 pounds while small ones only weigh around 1 pound each.

What is interesting about these tiny lobsters is that some of them live for more than ten years.

They also contain high amounts of protein which means that if you eat enough of them, you won’t have any problem with your diet.

There are two kinds of lobsters that we are going to talk about today – the spiny lobster and the poor man’s lobster.

Let us start with the latter first.

How to cook poor man’s lobster

Poor man’s lobster is usually cooked using steam or boiling method.

You should use the right temperature depending on how big the lobster is so don’t go overboard when cooking them.

First, take a large pot filled with water and bring it to boil.

Once it reaches 212 degrees Fahrenheit (100 Celsius), put the lobster inside.

When the water starts bubbling under the lid, reduce the heat to medium low.

Cook the lobster until its shell turns red and the meat becomes opaque.

Once the lobster is done, remove it from the pot immediately and add salt to the water.

Then, pour out the excess liquid into another container and discard.

After that, place the lobster back into the pot and let it cool down completely.

This process takes around 20 minutes.

What does poor man’s lobster look like?

You might think that poor man’s lobster looks nothing like a real lobster but that couldn’t be further from the truth.

These little guys come in various colors including white, pink, brown, black, orange, purple and yellow.

Their body length varies from 2 inches to 4 inches while their width ranges from 3/4 inch to 1 inch.

It is important to note that the smaller the lobster, the cheaper the price.

If you want to save some cash, choose an adult lobster instead of baby ones because they are much bigger and therefore, costlier.

What Are The Best Methods For Cooking Poor Man’s Lobster?

Lobsters are an expensive delicacy that comes from Maine in America.

They’re usually served with melted butter or mayonnaise as well as lemon juice or other citrus fruits.

The most common method used to cook them involves boiling lobsters until they turn red and die within minutes.

However, there are several ways to prepare poor man’s lobster which include baking, frying, broiling, grilling, roasting, steaming, and sautéing them.

These methods enable us to get more flavor out of the crustacean while keeping its freshness intact.

Baking is one such method that has been around since ancient times.

Lobster baked in their shells are called “baked Alaska” because of the resemblance of the dish to the dessert.

However, if you want something different, here is how to bake your own poor man’s lobster.

  • First, remove all the meat from the shell and set aside. Next, put some oil into a pan over medium heat. When hot, add the lobster tails and sear on both sides for about 2-3 minutes each side. Remove from pan and let cool slightly.
  • Cut off the claws and tail sections (the body) at the joint using scissors. Cut down the length of the body section so that you expose the center of the lobster.
  • Slice open the belly part of the lobster with a sharp knife. Using a spoon, scoop out any soft tissue inside the body cavity.
  • Using tweezers, pull out any remaining bits of sand left behind after cutting through the head area.
  • Put the lobster back together again but keep the claw and tail parts separate. Put oil back into the same pan and place the lobster pieces in the pan.
  • Cook over high heat until the flesh turns bright orange. Turn off the heat and cover with foil.
  • Let sit for 5 minutes, then use oven mitts to carefully pick up the cooked lobster pieces and place them onto a serving plate. Serve immediately with lemon wedges.
  • To serve the lobster legs separately, cut off the tip of the tail and peel away the skin and membrane covering the leg. Then just crack the shell and eat!

What Are Some Popular Poor Man’s Lobster Recipes?

The word “lobster” comes from the French term for female lobsters, which means “little girl” in English.

The name has nothing to do with how big or small they might be.

Lobsters come in many different sizes and shapes but most people prefer those that are smaller because they cost less and cook faster than larger ones.

If you like bigger lobsters, you may want to try them roasted on the grill instead of boiled.

Lobsters are one of the most expensive seafood items available.

In fact, about half of all Americans don’t even consider buying them at all.

They are so expensive because there is such high demand for them and only a very limited supply.

That said, if you really want to impress your guests with a unique meal, you should definitely give this dish a shot.

Here are some good things to know when preparing this delicious food item:

  • Most restaurants offer poor man’s lobster as an appetizer. You can also order it on its own as a main course. Either way, it is usually served with drawn butter sauce and steamed vegetables.
  • There are two types of lobster meat – claw meat and tail meat. Claw meat contains more flavor while tail meat is cheaper. Both are quite tasty but if you would rather save money, choose tail meat because it costs much less per pound.
  • When purchasing fresh lobster meat, always check the eyes of the live animal. A healthy eye indicates that the lobster is still alive. Do not buy any lobster with cloudy eyes or with black spots under their eyes. These signs indicate that the animal is close to death and its meat won’t be worth eating anyway.
  • You can eat lobster meat raw or cooked. Some chefs recommend soaking the claws and tails first in cold water to remove sand particles. After that, place them in boiling water until they turn bright red. Then drain and pat dry with paper towels. To prepare cooked lobster meat, simply boil for 10 minutes in salted water.
  • To serve, split open lobster shells using kitchen shears and remove the meat. Serve immediately with melted butter. For those who love spicy foods, add chopped jalapenos to the butter after melting it.

How to Make Poor Man\u2019s Lobster Recipe

Preparing poor man’s lobster is easy if you follow these steps carefully:

  • First, pick out the freshest lobster you can find. Look for lobsters that have unbroken claws and shiny green eyes. Avoid dead lobsters because they will smell bad and spoil quickly.
  • After picking your lobster, wash it thoroughly. Remove the soft shell and cut off the head and legs. Next, use kitchen scissors to cut through the body of the lobster to separate the claws and tail into several sections. Use a paring knife to pierce each section and pull out any remaining pieces of cartilage inside the lobster.
  • Remove the stomach sac located near the center of the lobster body. Place it aside for later use.
  • Next, take out the digestive tract (the part between the intestines and the stomach) and discard it. Wash the lobster well again, including the underside. Pat it dry with paper towels.
  • Now, put the lobster body back together. Cut along the sides of the lobster body where you removed the hard parts. Open up the lobster body and insert the head backward towards the tail end. Put the tail in a pot filled with cold water and bring it to a rolling boil. Boil the lobster for 12 minutes.
  • While the lobster is boiling, heat 2 tablespoons of olive oil in a frying pan over medium-high heat. Add garlic cloves and sauté for 1 minute. Stir in parsley and thyme leaves followed by crushed bay leaf. Cook for another 30 seconds.
  • Add lemon juice and stir well. Set aside.
  • Once the lobster turns bright red, transfer it to the prepared pan containing the herb mixture. Allow it to cool down completely. Once cooled, squeeze the lobster meat and strain the liquid to remove excess fat. Discard the rest of the liquid and set the meat aside.
  • Slice the lobster meat and arrange it on plates with melted butter on top. Garnish with additional herbs and serve immediately.

How Can I Make Poor Man’s Lobster More Sustainable?

Lobsters live in cold water and eat other things that live in cold water.

When you cook them, they lose their ability to swim away from predators or keep warm.

They also stop eating and die if they don’t get food for several days.

Lobster fishing kills lobsters as well because when one lobster gets caught in another lobster trap it suffocates itself trying to escape.

This means that lobsters need lots of space to grow and reproduce so they cannot survive in areas where there are too many people living nearby.

This problem is not unique to lobsters but all animals who depend on an environment with minimal human disturbances.

To solve these problems, we must learn how to balance our needs with those of the planet.

There are two ways to do this: Reduce your consumption levels and find new ways of harvesting the resources available to us.

  • Reduce Consumption Levels – One solution would be to reduce the number of times you consume lobster. By reducing the amount of meat you eat, you will save yourself the cost and waste associated with buying fresh lobster in stores. If you buy frozen lobster, you should only use it once every few months since freezing damages the meat.
  • Find New Ways of Harvesting Resources – Another option would be to look into alternatives to traditional methods of hunting and fishing. For example, instead of going out looking for fish, lobstermen could catch crabs using traps baited with dead fish. In addition, fishermen could set up nets along riverbanks to capture shrimp and other aquatic life. These options may seem extreme, but they show that there are plenty of alternative ways to harvest lobster than simply taking the ones swimming around in the ocean.

What Are The Environmental Impacts Of Poor Man’s Lobster Fishing?

Lobster is an expensive food item in many parts of the world.

Poor men tend to catch them using traps because they don’t have access to other types of equipment or capital that would allow them to buy traps instead.

Trapping lobsters is also one of the most dangerous jobs out there.

The U.S.

Department of Labor reports that between 2004-2014, 1,500 people lost their lives while working on lobster boats.

When someone catches a lobster with a trap, it usually means they are only able to sell the meat from two claws per pound.

Lobstering is not regulated by any government body, so there are no standards to ensure safety or humane treatment of animals.

Many fishermen do not even use cages when catching lobsters.

If a fisherman does not care about the environment, he may not take precautions to protect his own health and well being during the process of trapping lobsters.

Additionally, fishermen who fish illegally often throw dead lobsters back into the water after killing them, which causes further damage to marine ecosystems.

How Can I Make My Poor Man’s Lobster More Ethical?

Lobster has been around for thousands of years, but its popularity only started rising in recent decades when restaurants began serving them as an appetizer or main course.

Lobsters were once considered a luxury food item that was served at weddings, banquets, and other special occasions.

As time passed, people grew accustomed to eating lobsters on their own terms.

Today, they’re commonly found in supermarkets and specialty seafood stores across North America and Europe.

They are also available online from major retailers including Amazon.

However, there’s no denying that lobsters aren’t cheap.

The average price per pound varies depending on where you live.

For example, according to Seafood Watch, one pound of New England (NE) lobster costs $14.99-$19.99 in Boston, Massachusetts.

In Maine, however, one pound of lobster sold for between $22.29-$25.49.

While these prices may seem high compared with other types of fish, they still fall within the range of affordability.

With so many options out there, how do consumers choose which type of lobster to buy?

If you want to save money while enjoying quality meat, then you should know about the different kinds of lobster available in your area.

Here are three things to consider when choosing which lobster species to purchase:

  • The source
  • Size
  • Price

The Source

Most people prefer to eat lobster caught off the coast of Canada, particularly Nova Scotia.

However, if you don’t mind traveling farther than this region, then you can opt for lobster from other parts of the world, such as South Africa, Chile, Australia, Brazil, Argentina, Spain, United Kingdom, Norway, Ireland, Italy, France, Portugal, Scotland, Malta, Turkey, Japan, China, Thailand, Mexico, Peru, and India.


When buying lobster, size matters.

Smaller lobsters are less expensive and easier to catch.

On the other hand, larger lobsters typically cost more because they require more hands to harvest.

You need large boats, heavy equipment, and skilled workers who know exactly when to release each individual lobster.

It’s not just the size that affects the price either.

Some breeds are hardier than others and therefore take longer to cook.

If you plan to use your lobster right away, then it doesn’t really matter whether it’s small or big.


Another thing that influences the price of lobster is location.

As noted above, lobster prices vary widely based on where you live.

Prices also depend on the season since freshness plays an important role in determining overall value.

When purchasing lobster, keep in mind that prices tend to rise during peak seasons like summer months.

You might think that all lobsters come from the same place, but in reality, they differ significantly in appearance, flavor, texture, smell, and even color.

There are several ways to determine the origin of your lobster:

  • Look for certification seals
  • Check the country name printed on the box or bag
  • Ask questions
  • Read reviews

To learn more about how to select the best lobster species for you, check out our guide below.

What Are The Social Implications Of Eating Poor Man’s Lobster?

Lobster has long been considered an expensive food item when compared with other seafood.

However, if you think about how much labor goes into harvesting lobsters from the ocean, they really aren’t that expensive at all.

In fact, one large lobster (which weighs approximately 2 lbs) could feed a person for three days in some parts of the world! So, while we may not feel guilty eating lobster as often as we do beef or chicken, there is something to consider here.

In recent years, lobster fishing has become increasingly unsustainable due to overfishing.

The most significant cause of this problem is the demand for lobster meat from Japan and China, which accounts for 70% of global imports.

This means that many fishermen are forced to catch larger numbers of lobsters than they would otherwise be able to sustainably harvest, resulting in fewer lobsters being available overall.

This also results in less income for fishermen who rely on their livelihoods off of lobster.

As a result of this, fisherman are now turning towards alternative methods of making a living, such as aquaculture and tourism.

For example, the Lobster Coast Aquafarm in Canada is responsible for raising 100,000 young lobsters every year.

These young lobsters grow quickly and require very little care once they reach maturity, so they are ideal candidates for farmers looking to raise their own lobster stocks.

The Lobster Coast Aquafarm even provides tourists with the opportunity to visit the farm and learn more about these animals.

They offer tours where visitors can get up close and personal with the lobsters in order to learn more about them and see just how hard they work.

As more people turn away from traditional lobster fisheries and toward alternative farming practices like those found on the Lobster Coast Aquafarm, the price of lobster continues to decrease.

While this might seem like good news, one side effect of decreasing prices is that it becomes easier to eat lobster cheaply without feeling bad about yourself.

Is Poor Man’s

Lobster is an expensive delicacy that has become more popular over time.

In the past, lobsters were only found in coastal areas where there was plentiful fish life.

Today, however, they are now widely available throughout the world due to globalization.

The price for one pound of lobster varies from $25-$45 depending on location and season.

The cost of living varies significantly between different parts of the globe so it isn’t easy for people who live outside of North America or Europe to afford this luxury item.

One way some families get around this problem is by cooking their own lobster at home using recipes like this one below.

Poor Man’s Lobster Recipe – Ingredients:

  • 1 lb cooked lobster meat (about 4 medium sized claws)
  • ½ cup butter (melted)
  • ¼ teaspoon salt
  • 3 tablespoons flour
  • 4 cups milk
  • 3 eggs beaten with ½ tablespoon cream
  • 1/8 teaspoon pepper


  • Cut up lobster meat into bite size pieces.
  • Melt 1 Tablespoon of butter in pan.
  • Add flour and stir until well mixed.
  • Continue stirring constantly while adding milk slowly until mixture thickens slightly.
  • Remove from heat & add remaining butter (melted), egg yolk, and seasoning, mix thoroughly.
  • Pour half of batter into hot skillet containing melted butter
  • Cover skillet tightly with foil or lid, place on stove top burner, and cook 10 minutes or until crust forms.
  • Uncover skillet, remove foil cover or lid, and continue to cook 5 additional minutes.
  • Turn off burner, let sit for 3 minutes, then serve immediately.

This recipe should take about 20 minutes to prepare and costs less than buying frozen lobster tails from your local grocery store.

You can also buy prepared lobster buttermilk sauce for an extra charge.

What Is The Difference Between Poor Man’s Lobster And Regular Lobster?

The most popular variety of lobster in America are those known as “rock lobsters” or “spiny lobsters.” These lobsters are found along the Atlantic coast from Maine down to Florida.

They are also called North American lobsters because they are native to these waters.

The name “rock lobster” comes from their spines which are often visible under the shell when alive.

Rock lobster meat has an interesting flavor that many people find appealing, but not everyone does.

If you do not like rock lobster meat, there are other varieties that may appeal to your palate better.

Another type of lobster that is much less common than the above two types are the ones called “poor man’s lobster” or simply “lobster.” Poor man’s lobster are smaller than the others, and tend to lack the delicious flavors present in larger versions.

Because of its size, the price for a poor man’s lobster is usually quite high compared to the price of rock lobster.

Another reason why poor man’s lobster are so expensive is that they are harvested from very small areas where fishing is difficult.

Many people who eat poor man’s lobster say that they prefer eating them cooked instead of raw.

This recipe allows you to cook a large amount of poor man’s lobster at once, making it easier on yourself if you want to serve a big group.

The only thing that you need to buy in order to complete this dish is some seafood seasoning and fresh lemon juice.

You should also prepare enough water to cover all of the lobster shells, since every time you add another piece of lobster, it causes the water level to drop.

After preparing your ingredients, start with cooking the lobster first.

Once the lobster meat is done, remove it from the pot and put it into containers.

Next, sauté the onion and garlic until translucent, then stir in the tomato sauce.

Add the cream cheese, mix well, and bring everything back up to temperature.

Serve immediately!

What Are The Benefits Of Eating Poor Man’s Lobster?

There are many reasons why we should eat lobster regularly.

The first reason is that it has an incredible flavor with no artificial ingredients or preservatives.

It’s also rich in protein and low on calories.

If you want to lose weight, this is one dish you can add to your diet without feeling guilty about it.

Lobsters are known for being expensive.

In fact, they are considered luxury food items rather than cheap snacks.

However, there is another option available for those who don’t like to spend too much money on their meals.

With this method, you can still get the same delicious experience as if you were dining at a fancy restaurant.

What Is The Nutritional Value Of Poor Man’s Lobster?

Lobster has long been considered an expensive food item.

However, with the rise in popularity of healthy eating, more people now know that they can eat lobster for less than $10 per pound, which makes it affordable enough to purchase on a regular basis.

The following chart illustrates how much protein, fat, carbohydrates, fiber, iron, calcium, vitamin A, riboflavin, thiamine, niacin, and zinc each serving contains.

It’s important to note that these values are based on one-third cup of cooked lobster meat.

If you were to choose raw or undercooked lobster, the nutritional content would change significantly.

For example, if you chose raw lobster instead of cooked lobster, your daily intake of vitamin C would drop from about 30 mg down to 15 mg.

This does not mean that you should avoid purchasing lobster altogether – there are many benefits associated with its consumption, including low cholesterol levels, high blood pressure reduction, cancer prevention, heart health promotion, improved immune system function, and weight control.

However, when choosing between different types of seafood, lobster tends to be priced higher than other options because of its rarity.

In fact, only 2% of all lobsters caught are female.

Female lobsters also tend to grow larger than male lobsters, so their price goes up as well.

Lobsters do not reproduce until they reach at least five years old.

In addition to being delicious, lobster is nutritious.

So, even though you may think that buying poor man’s lobster might save you some money, it won’t necessarily translate into lower prices at the grocery store!

What Are The Best Methods For Cooking Poor Man’s Lobster?

Lobster is an expensive delicacy that requires careful attention in order to cook it right.

Lobsters live on sponges which they eat as their main source of nutrition.

They also consume plankton and other small creatures like shrimp and fish eggs.

In addition to being delicious, lobster has many health benefits.

For example, it contains large amounts of vitamin B12, zinc, protein, omega-3 fatty acids, iron, copper, magnesium, selenium, and calcium.

There are two types of lobsters available today:

  • Atlantic or Maine lobster – The Atlantic lobster lives on rocks, and its shell color ranges from greenish white to blue gray with brown stripes.
  • Rock lobster – Rock lobster lives on sandy bottoms near rocky shores.

The most important thing you need to know when buying lobster is that it should not smell bad.

If you notice any unpleasant odor coming out of the container, do not buy it.

What Are Some Popular Poor Man’s Lobster Recipes?

The first thing that comes to mind when people think about lobster is its delicious flavor.

Lobster is rich in protein which means it is an excellent source of energy.

The meat also has healthy omega-3 fatty acids, zinc, selenium, vitamin A, B12, D, E, K, and iron.

These nutrients provide protection against diseases such as cancer and heart disease.

Lobsters are also good sources of calcium, phosphorus, magnesium, copper, sodium, and potassium.

They contain no cholesterol or trans fats.

However, they do contain small amounts of mercury and lead.

If these metals exceed acceptable limits, eating them could cause damage to your body.

For this reason, it’s important to learn how to cook lobster properly so that you don’t end up with any health problems from consuming too much.

Here is a list of some of the most common lobster dishes:

  • Poor Man’s Lobster Bisque
  • Crawfish Boil
  • Grilled Lobster Pasta Salad
  • Crab Cakes
  • Lobster Rolls
  • Shrimp Cocktail
  • Spicy Lobster Roll Soup
  • Jerk Shrimp
  • Risotto de Arroz con Langosta (lobster risotto)
  • Lobster Thermidor
  • Mangoes Stuffed With Crabmeat And Lobster
  • Lobster Tails In Wine Sauce
  • Terrific Tuna Casserole
  • Chowder Clam Chowder
  • Prawn Crepe
  • Seafood Gumbo

How Can I Make Poor Man’s Lobster More Sustainable?

Poor Man’s Lobster Recipe – The name says it all! The ingredients for this dish are extremely inexpensive but that does not mean that they are easy to find or affordable.

However, if you want to save money on your meal, you should try making this delicious recipe at home.

This recipe has been around since the 1800’s when fishermen would catch lobsters in their nets and boil them alive so they could sell them as cheap food.

They were also known as “poor men’s lobster” because most people couldn’t afford to eat lobster back then.

Today, we know better than to kill our fellow creatures just to satisfy our hunger.

This recipe uses fresh lobster meat from Maine, which means that there is no need to kill any animals.

It might seem like killing an animal for dinner isn’t very ethical but it really depends on how you look at things.

If you take into account the fact that you are actually feeding yourself instead of someone else, then eating lobster becomes much less harmful.

In addition, many species of lobster live off of other organisms and don’t harm anything while doing so.

So, next time you order lobster, think about how lucky you are to even get to experience this delicacy, let alone enjoy it.

You shouldn’t feel bad about enjoying something that others cannot.

After all, if everyone did that, nobody would ever have anything to complain about.

What Are The Environmental Impacts Of Poor Man’s Lobster Fishing?

Lobster fishing in North America has some very serious environmental issues that threaten its future sustainability.

Lobsters live in shallow coastal waters where they feed on other smaller fish and invertebrates such as shrimp, clams, crabs, and worms.

Unfortunately, overfishing is one of the biggest threats to these creatures’ survival.

Overfishing causes lobsters to decrease their feeding habits which leads them to become less efficient at catching prey.

In turn, this reduces their ability to reproduce, making them even easier for predators like humans to catch.

Another problem with overfishing is that it depletes the amount of oxygen available in the water.

When there isn’t enough oxygen, many marine animals die from lack of oxygen or suffocate because they cannot swim away quickly enough from an approaching predator.

In addition to overfishing, pollution also poses a significant threat to lobster populations.

The runoff from agricultural areas into bodies of water contains chemicals that kill the organisms living near rivers and lakes.

These poisons affect both the fish and the lobsters who eat those fish.

As a result, fewer lobsters survive and eventually disappear completely.

How Can I Make My Poor Man’s Lobster More Ethical?

Lobster is very expensive when bought in stores or restaurants.

In order for people to afford lobster, they often choose to cook their own at home instead of buying from professional chefs.

But there are many downsides to cooking your own lobster.

  • The only thing worse than not having enough time to prepare food is also being too busy to do so. When you eat out at a restaurant, you know that everything has been prepared with care and attention to detail. You don’t have to worry about whether or not the kitchen staff did anything wrong while preparing your meal because you trusted them with your safety. However, if you decide to cook your own lobster, you take on all responsibilities yourself, including making sure that everything goes according to plan.
  • You need to buy fresh seafood which isn’t always available everywhere. If you live far away from the ocean, you may find it difficult to get the lobsters you want. Also, some people avoid purchasing wild caught fish due to concerns over sustainability. Lobster is considered sustainable as long as fishermen follow regulations set forth by the government and the local community.
  • There may be times where you run into problems after you purchase your lobster. For example, if you didn’t read the instructions properly, you could end up hurting yourself during preparation. If you aren’t careful, you might spill boiling water onto yourself or cause an accident with other equipment. These things happen even in the best kitchens.

Poor Man’s Lobster Recipe Tips

While cooking your own lobster doesn’t guarantee perfect results every single time, here are some tips to keep in mind:

  • Buy large lobsters rather than small ones. While the price per pound decreases as size increases, the amount of meat in larger lobsters tends to outweigh the cost difference. The same applies for shrimp and clams.
  • Cooking directions vary depending on how much flesh you want to remove from each lobster. Some recipes call for removing the tail first, followed by the claws. Others suggest removing the body of the lobster with its head intact. To remove the entire body, you should cut off the head last.
  • Don’t use old pots. Old pots tend to break easily and are prone to rusting. Use new pots whenever possible.
  • Use tongs to pick up the lobster. A fork can sometimes damage soft-shell crabs (such as Maine blueberry) or shrimps.
  • Remove any unneeded parts before cooking. There are cases where you’ll see “eyes” hanging off the lobster but these eyes are actually edible. Remove them before cooking otherwise they will become tough and dry.
  • Make sure you buy fresh lobster. Frozen lobsters are just as good as those available year round. They’re still alive so they won’t spoil quickly once thawed.
  • Keep an eye on the pot during cooking. Make sure the heat stays high enough throughout the process or else you risk overcooking your crab or lobster.
  • Try soaking lobster tails in ice water prior to cooking. This helps prevent the shells from cracking open during cooking. Be careful though! Never soak the bodies of the lobster.

What Are The Social Implications Of Eating Poor Man’s Lobster?

Lobster is one of those foods that people tend to love or hate.

The truth is, there isn’t much in between.

If you like lobster, chances are good that you also love seafood.

Lobsters are typically expensive since they require large amounts of space on the ocean floor.

They take years for their shells to fully grow into adulthood.

When they reach maturity, they need to be harvested and transported back to land where they spend several months being processed by humans until they finally become edible.

To add insult to injury, the fishermen who catch these lobsters use extremely dangerous methods which often result in them losing their lives.

So when you think about how difficult it must be to catch a lobster and prepare it, you might begin to wonder if it would be better just to eat your cat instead!

Is Poor Man’s

This recipe is a great way to enjoy the taste of lobster without spending a lot of money.

It is simple to make and can be enjoyed by the whole family.

The first step in making poor man’s lobster is finding some fresh lobsters that are not too expensive.

If you live near a seafood market or fish store, this should be easy for most people.

However, if you do not live close enough to such an establishment, look around your local grocery stores.

You may find frozen lobster meat available there as well.

Just remember that frozen lobster meat does not contain any of the delicious juices found in fresh meat.

Once you have located the lobster meat, place it into a bowl along with some lemon juice.

Next, sprinkle salt on top of the lobster.

Salt helps keep the lobster from going bad, so use as much as you want.

After adding salt to the lobster, let it sit at room temperature for about 20 minutes.

Then, add butter to the mixture and stir until all pieces of lobster meat have been coated with butter.

When finished stirring, put everything into a large pot over medium-high heat.

Once heated up, cover the pot and allow the dish to cook for five minutes.

After five minutes, remove the lid and continue cooking the lobster for another 5-10 minutes.

The final phase of cooking involves taking out the lobster meat after 15 minutes.

Remove the pot from the stove once the lobster has cooked through, but still retains its firmness.

Place the lobster back onto the plate where it was sitting earlier.

Serve immediately!

Poor Mans Lobster Recipe

Poor Man’s Lobster is defined as lobster meat that has not been boiled or cooked in any other method than steaming.
Prep Time: 10 minutes
Cook Time: 5 minutes
Total Time: 15 minutes
Course: Dinner, Main Course
Cuisine: American
Keyword: Poor Mans Lobster Recipe
Calories: 2110kcal


  • 1 lb White Fish cod
  • ½ cup Sugar
  • ¼ cup Salt
  • 6 oz Butter
  • 12 cups Water
  • Paprika
  • Pepper


  • The white fish fillets should be divided into 2 inch wide pieces.
  • Heat the water until it boils. Stir in the salt and sugar until they are completely dissolved.
  • Lower the fish pieces into the boiling water using tongs.
  • Cook for approximately 7 minutes, or until the fish starts to flake.
  • Remove the fish using a skimmer, then add it to the bowl containing the melted butter.
  • After removing from the butter, rub the fillet pieces with lemon juice.
  • Serve warm.



Calories: 2110kcal | Carbohydrates: 118g | Protein: 93g | Fat: 146g | Saturated Fat: 90g | Polyunsaturated Fat: 7g | Monounsaturated Fat: 38g | Trans Fat: 6g | Cholesterol: 593mg | Sodium: 29766mg | Potassium: 1419mg | Sugar: 118g | Vitamin A: 4251IU | Calcium: 190mg | Iron: 3mg
Tried this recipe?Let us know how it was!
Follow me